Coney Island Homes with Waterfront

Coney Island Homes with Waterfront

Welcome to Coney Island, a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Treasure Island, Florida! This charming subdivision is renowned for its idyllic waterfront properties that offer breathtaking views and a serene coastal lifestyle. If you're dreaming of waking up to the gentle sound of waves and the sight of stunning sunsets over the shimmering waters, Coney Island is the perfect place to call home.

Located in Pinellas County, Coney Island boasts a unique blend of tranquility and convenience. Residents enjoy easy access to the pristine beaches of Treasure Island, where sun-soaked days and water activities await. Whether you’re a fan of paddleboarding, fishing, or simply soaking up the sun, the waterfront lifestyle here is nothing short of enchanting.

The homes in Coney Island are a true reflection of the coastal charm that defines this area. Many properties feature direct access to the water, allowing you to indulge in a variety of aquatic adventures right from your backyard. Imagine hosting family gatherings or intimate dinners with the mesmerizing backdrop of the Gulf of Mexico. With a variety of architectural styles, from classic Florida bungalows to modern waterfront estates, you’re sure to find a home that matches your personal taste.

Beyond the stunning homes and vibrant waterfront, Coney Island offers a close-knit community feel, with friendly neighbors and a welcoming atmosphere. Explore local parks, indulge in delightful dining options, or take a leisurely stroll along the beach—life in Coney Island is all about enjoying the best of Florida living.

Discover the magic of Coney Island today, and let your dream of waterfront living become a reality!

Newest Coney Island Homes with Waterfront

$3,250,000
5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ W7888215 MLS
Own one of Treasure Island's rarest beachfront compounds. Featuring The Pink Flamingo and The Blue Dolphin—two fully renovated Gulf-front homes generating nearly $300,000 in annual gross rental income—this turnkey legacy property offers the perfect blend of luxury living, proven cash flow, and irreplaceable direct beach frontage. Celebrated for their distinctive 1950s retro coastal theme, The Pink Flamingo and The Blue Dolphin have become iconic beachfront destinations, where vintage Old Florida charm meets modern comfort. Every detail has been thoughtfully designed to capture the nostalgia of a bygone era while providing today's guests with the quality and amenities they expect. The result is a truly memorable experience that has earned nothing but 5-star reviews and a loyal base of repeat visitors who return year after year. Behind the timeless aesthetic lies a property that has been meticulously updated for peace of mind and long-term value. Both homes feature impact-rated windows and doors, combining enhanced storm protection with energy efficiency, quiet interiors, and abundant natural light—all while preserving their unique character and curb appeal. With an established rental business, proven financial performance, and nearly $300,000 in annual gross revenue, you'll step into immediate cash flow while enjoying the flexibility to use the property however you choose. Live in one home and rent the other, continue operating both as premier vacation rentals, or create the ultimate multi-generational beachfront retreat for family and friends. The Pink Flamingo offers spacious accommodations, vibrant retro-inspired décor, and breathtaking Gulf views that make every stay unforgettable. Just steps away, The Blue Dolphin complements the experience with its own distinctive personality and inviting atmosphere, creating the perfect pairing for larger groups, extended families, or dual rental opportunities. Together, they form a one-of-a-kind beachfront compound that simply cannot be replicated. Step outside and the Gulf of Mexico becomes your backyard. Spend your mornings with coffee overlooking the water, your afternoons with your toes in the sugar-white sand, and your evenings watching spectacular sunsets from your private beachfront oasis. It's the quintessential Florida lifestyle that guests rave about and one that few properties can truly offer. For investors, the value extends well beyond the real estate itself. You're acquiring an established hospitality business with a proven operating history, exceptional guest satisfaction, and a recognizable identity that sets it apart in a competitive market. The combination of all 5-star ratings, repeat clientele, and turnkey operations provides a solid foundation for continued success from day one. Perfectly situated in the heart of Treasure Island, you're just minutes from waterfront dining, shopping, boating, entertainment, and John's Pass while still enjoying the privacy and tranquility of direct beachfront living. Properties offering two separate Gulf-front homes, a proven six-figure income stream, distinctive branding, modern upgrades, and an irreplaceable location are extraordinarily rare. The Pink Flamingo and The Blue Dolphin are more than vacation rentals—they are beloved destinations that blend nostalgia, luxury, and investment potential into one unforgettable opportunity. Note - There is also a second lot included that is in front of the lot with the houses.

12609 Sunshine Lane, Treasure Island
$3,250,000
5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ W7885505 MLS
Own one of Treasure Island's rarest beachfront compounds. Featuring The Pink Flamingo and The Blue Dolphin—two fully renovated Gulf-front homes generating nearly $300,000 in annual gross rental income—this turnkey legacy property offers the perfect blend of luxury living, proven cash flow, and irreplaceable direct beach frontage. Celebrated for their distinctive 1950s retro coastal theme, The Pink Flamingo and The Blue Dolphin have become iconic beachfront destinations, where vintage Old Florida charm meets modern comfort. Every detail has been thoughtfully designed to capture the nostalgia of a bygone era while providing today's guests with the quality and amenities they expect. The result is a truly memorable experience that has earned nothing but 5-star reviews and a loyal base of repeat visitors who return year after year. Behind the timeless aesthetic lies a property that has been meticulously updated for peace of mind and long-term value. Both homes feature impact-rated windows and doors, combining enhanced storm protection with energy efficiency, quiet interiors, and abundant natural light—all while preserving their unique character and curb appeal. With an established rental business, proven financial performance, and nearly $300,000 in annual gross revenue, you'll step into immediate cash flow while enjoying the flexibility to use the property however you choose. Live in one home and rent the other, continue operating both as premier vacation rentals, or create the ultimate multi-generational beachfront retreat for family and friends. The Pink Flamingo offers spacious accommodations, vibrant retro-inspired décor, and breathtaking Gulf views that make every stay unforgettable. Just steps away, The Blue Dolphin complements the experience with its own distinctive personality and inviting atmosphere, creating the perfect pairing for larger groups, extended families, or dual rental opportunities. Together, they form a one-of-a-kind beachfront compound that simply cannot be replicated. Step outside and the Gulf of Mexico becomes your backyard. Spend your mornings with coffee overlooking the water, your afternoons with your toes in the sugar-white sand, and your evenings watching spectacular sunsets from your private beachfront oasis. It's the quintessential Florida lifestyle that guests rave about and one that few properties can truly offer. For investors, the value extends well beyond the real estate itself. You're acquiring an established hospitality business with a proven operating history, exceptional guest satisfaction, and a recognizable identity that sets it apart in a competitive market. The combination of all 5-star ratings, repeat clientele, and turnkey operations provides a solid foundation for continued success from day one. Perfectly situated in the heart of Treasure Island, you're just minutes from waterfront dining, shopping, boating, entertainment, and John's Pass while still enjoying the privacy and tranquility of direct beachfront living. Properties offering two separate Gulf-front homes, a proven six-figure income stream, distinctive branding, modern upgrades, and an irreplaceable location are extraordinarily rare. The Pink Flamingo and The Blue Dolphin are more than vacation rentals—they are beloved destinations that blend nostalgia, luxury, and investment potential into one unforgettable opportunity. Note - There is also a second lot included that is in front of the lot with the houses.

12609 Sunshine Lane, Treasure Island
$999,000
TB8492350 MLS
This is a land opportunity in one of the most desirable boating locations on the Treasure Island. The existing structure is a tear down. The value is in the lot and the waterfront position. The property offers a 46 by 100 lot with 50 feet BEYOND THE DOCK deeded into the water, giving you control and flexibility to build with confidence. The dock was repaired after the 2024 storms and includes a 10,000 lb lift. The water is deep, protected, and positioned for serious boating. You are just off John’s Pass, which means fast access to the Gulf and an easy ride to multiple waterfront restaurants. The street is quiet and set back from Gulf Blvd, reducing traffic while still keeping you close to beaches, dining, and daily conveniences. Zoning allows for single family or duplex, which opens the door for personal use, income production, or a combination of both. Public water and sewer are in place. The existing structure already has 200 amp service, which can simplify your planning process. Many properties in Treasure Island are coming to market following the 2024 storm season. What sets this one apart is the combination of boating depth, protected water, proximity to the Pass, and flexible zoning. Those four factors are difficult to find together.

12620 Lagoon Lane, Treasure Island
Start Your Search