Keystone Heights Homes for Sale

Keystone Heights Homes for Sale

Welcome to Keystone Heights, Florida—a hidden gem nestled between the serene lakes and lush landscapes of North Central Florida. Known for its quaint charm and friendly community, Keystone Heights offers a perfect blend of small-town warmth and modern conveniences. With its picturesque surroundings, including the stunning Lake Geneva and Lake Santa Fe, residents enjoy a plethora of outdoor activities such as fishing, boating, and hiking.

The city boasts a rich history and a vibrant community spirit, making it an ideal place for families, retirees, and everyone in between. With a range of local shops, eateries, and recreational facilities, Keystone Heights fosters a sense of belonging that is hard to replicate. The annual events and community gatherings bring residents together, creating lasting friendships and cherished memories.

Now is an exciting time to explore the homes for sale in Keystone Heights. From charming cottages to spacious family homes, the real estate market here offers something for everyone. Many properties feature beautiful gardens, modern amenities, and easy access to the area's natural wonders. Whether you’re looking for a cozy retreat or a larger home to accommodate a growing family, Keystone Heights has options that cater to diverse lifestyles and budgets.

Discover the joys of living in Keystone Heights, where tranquil living meets vibrant community life. With a welcoming atmosphere and an array of homes for sale, your dream home awaits in this enchanting Florida town. Come experience the charm of Keystone Heights—your new home is just a visit away!

Newest Keystone Heights Homes for Sale

$350,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ GC542817 MLS
Welcome to Silver Sands Lake, where everyday life comes with a little more sunshine and a whole lot more relaxation! Tucked away on a beautiful half-acre lakefront lot in Keystone Heights in North Florida, this charming two story 3 bedroom/ 2 bathroom lake home is ready for someone who appreciates slow mornings and sunset views. Additionally there is a separate small home office making work from home at the lake a breeze! Step outside to the large deck off the main living area and kitchen area, which is perfect for grilling, entertaining friends and sipping your morning coffee to enjoy the view. There is a 2nd den/living area downstairs with a fireplace and the owner's suite which gives privacy and has its own separate exterior door to a patio overlooking the lake. Follow the path down toward the water and discover your own lakeside retreat, complete with a seawall and a little gazebo closer down by the sandy beach that leads to the water’s edge. Which is a perfect spot for fishing, watching wildlife, or ending the day with a spectacular sunset. Need room for the toys, tools, or weekend projects? There is a detached garage that gives you that extra space while keeping the main home uncluttered. Its an easy commute to Gainesville, Middleburg, Palatka or Jacksonville. Whether you're looking for a full-time home on the lake, a weekend escape, or simply a place where the lake becomes part of your everyday lifestyle, this property has all the ingredients for making memories. Bring your kayak, fishing pole, favorite lawn chair, and a good book—lake life is waiting for you!

5616 Silver Sands Circle, Keystone Heights
$185,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ GC541376 MLS
Concrete Block Home! This comfortable 3 bedroom 1.5 bath house has 1360 sq ft of living space and sits on 0.27 acres of land. Open concept! Updated with new luxury vinyl plank flooring in the living room and hallway, new French doors off the dining area, and fresh coat of paint inside and out. The home has a custom painted concrete floor in the kitchen-dining area, carpet in the bedrooms, and an attic fan in the hallway. The hallway half bathroom is connected to the primary bathroom by a shared bathtub. The property has a fenced backyard with plenty of shade and is located just over half a mile from Keystone Heights schools. Don't miss out on this great opportunity!

475 Sw Nightingale Street, Keystone Heights
$1,799,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ GC542277 MLS
Custom built in 2023 and set on a secluded five-acre peninsula, this one-of-a-kind Gated Lake Brooklyn estate offers an extraordinary opportunity to own a private waterfront retreat where luxury, recreation, and unforgettable family memories come together. Surrounded by majestic live oaks draped in Spanish moss, the property captures the timeless beauty of Old Florida while showcasing exceptional craftsmanship and modern design in one of North Florida's most remarkable lakefront settings. Offering over 3,000 heated square feet of thoughtfully designed living space, the residence features soaring vaulted ceilings with exposed wood beams, wide-plank flooring, an open-concept design, and expansive windows that frame breathtaking lake views from nearly every room. At the heart of the home, the chef's kitchen flows seamlessly into the spacious great room before opening to a spectacular covered lanai complete with a full outdoor kitchen, multiple entertaining areas, and panoramic waterfront views. Whether enjoying coffee as the sun rises over the lake or gathering with friends and family at sunset, every space was thoughtfully designed to embrace the beauty of waterfront living. The flexible floor plan offers four bedrooms and four bathrooms, with every main-level bedroom featuring its own private en-suite bath. The luxurious primary suite is a true retreat, offering sweeping lake views, a spa-inspired bathroom, and two generous walk-in closets. A dedicated office provides the flexibility to serve as a fifth bedroom if desired. Upstairs, a private guest suite includes its own bedroom and full bathroom, along with an oversized bunk room that comfortably accommodates six beds, creating the perfect space for grandchildren, extended family, or unforgettable weekends at the lake. Designed with both recreation and versatility in mind, the property also includes two exceptional detached buildings. One oversized garage offers abundant space for boats, RVs, golf carts, side-by-sides, and all of your lake toys and recreational equipment. The second is a climate-controlled building complete with two garage bays, a full bathroom, workshop space, and a mini-split system, providing endless possibilities as a home gym, studio, office, workshop, or future guest casita for family and visitors. Floating Tommy Dock offers customazation for your waterfront needs. Whether you're searching for a primary residence or the ultimate second home, this exceptional property was built for making memories. Spend your days boating, fishing, paddleboarding, tubing, or skiing before gathering with family and friends to watch spectacular sunsets over the water. Set on a rare five-acre peninsula with water surrounding three sides, the home offers an ever-changing backdrop of breathtaking views, spectacular sunrises, and unforgettable sunsets. This is more than a lake house. It's a legacy property where generations of family and friends will gather, celebrate, and create memories for years to come. Conveniently located approximately 45 minutes from Jacksonville and an easy drive from Gainesville, this is a rare opportunity to own one of Lake Brooklyn's most exceptional waterfront estates.

7229 Pleasant Point Road, Keystone Heights
$245,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ GC542078 MLS
Bring your vision and transform this diamond in the rough into your dream waterfront retreat. Situated on a spacious 0.27-acre fully fenced lot on beautiful Lake Geneva, this approximately 1,600-square-foot home is full of potential for investors, flippers, or buyers looking to create their own lakeside getaway. The home features a generous 400-square-foot open back porch overlooking the expansive backyard. As Lake Geneva's water levels rise with the planned pipeline project, this porch is expected to offer beautiful lake views and the perfect space for relaxing, entertaining, or enjoying peaceful sunsets. While the home does need TLC and updating, the combination of a large fenced yard, waterfront location, and future lake improvements creates an exceptional opportunity to build equity. Whether you're searching for a weekend retreat, investment property, or full-time residence, this property offers endless possibilities in a desirable lakefront setting. Don't miss your chance to invest in the future of Lake Geneva and make this property your own!

7908 Lake Geneva Lane, Keystone Heights
$825,000
5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ GC541111 MLS
Welcome to a truly one of a kind Lake Geneva waterfront retreat. Nestled among mature trees and lush landscaping, this remarkable property feels like your own private botanical garden, featuring more than 50 palm trees, hundreds of azaleas and camellias, and a variety of fruit trees including navel oranges, citrus, figs, and pears. With over 125 feet of shoreline, breathtaking lake views are showcased throughout the home. Offering 3,294 square feet, 5 bedrooms, and 3 bathrooms, this lovingly maintained home has been enjoyed by only two owners and is thoughtfully designed for both everyday living and entertaining. Two front entrances welcome you inside, where the family room with a fireplace, dining room, and living room with a second fireplace flow seamlessly together. Expansive windows frame stunning views of the lake and fill the home with natural light. The spacious kitchen features new appliances, abundant storage, and a window above the sink overlooking the pool and lake. Enjoy easy access to outdoor living from both the kitchen nook and living room. The centrally located primary suite offers a private en-suite bathroom and convenient access to the main living areas. A desirable split floor plan provides privacy for family and guests, with two bedrooms and a shared bathroom located near the laundry room on one side of the home and two additional bedrooms sharing a bathroom on the opposite side. Step outside and discover the true magic of this property. The 30 x 40 in ground pool is complemented by a brand new oversized deck and concrete surround, creating the perfect setting for entertaining, relaxing, and enjoying the peaceful waterfront setting. An outdoor shower adds convenience after a day spent swimming or enjoying the lake. Recent updates include a new roof in 2024, exterior painting in 2025, new appliances, and extensive improvements to the pool area. Rarely does a property provide this combination of waterfront living, mature landscaping, privacy, and timeless charm. This is more than a home, it is a treasured Lake Geneva retreat ready for its next chapter.

3933 Se State Road 21, Keystone Heights
$334,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ GC540657 MLS
PROPERTY ALLOWS FOR AN ADU - PLEASE CONTACT LISTING AGENT FOR FURTHER DETAILS. Beautifully updated 3-bedroom, 2-bath home situated on 2.5 private acres offering the perfect blend of comfort, space, and functionality. This charming property features approximately 1,350 heated and cooled square feet (2,090 total gross sq ft), with inviting front and rear porches ideal for relaxing and enjoying the peaceful surroundings. This property already has a 30-Amp RV Hookup. The home has been thoughtfully renovated inside and showcases warm cedar siding on the exterior, adding timeless character and curb appeal. A standout feature is the newly built 900 sq ft metal workshop with a concrete slab—perfect for hobbies, storage, or a home-based business. With room to roam, recent upgrades, and versatile outdoor space, this property provides endless possibilities for country living while still being conveniently located.

5040 Rodeo Drive, Keystone Heights
$350,000
5 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ GC540505 MLS
Seller is offering a $10,000 credit toward the buyer's rate buy-down or closing costs — plus, with the private ADU, this property offers built-in cashflow potential to help offset your monthly mortgage payment. Welcome to a property that's been methodically upgraded from the roof down, offering the kind of peace of mind that only comes from a home that's been truly cared for. Nestled in the serene Keystone Heights community, this unique offering features a main residence plus a private ADU (Accessory Dwelling Unit), making it ideal for multi-generational living, rental income potential, or simply the gift of extra space. The main house tells a story of smart, sustained investment. A metal roof (2015) has stood strong for over a decade, while brand-new AC ductwork (2023) and a new AC unit (2026) ensure efficient, reliable climate control for years to come. Fresh LVP flooring (2024) runs throughout, delivering a clean, modern feel underfoot, and newly upgraded attic insulation to R-30 value (2026) means lower energy bills and a more comfortable home year-round. The septic system was professionally cleaned (2026), so the next owner starts fresh with zero deferred maintenance. The ADU received its own round of major upgrades; a new metal roof (2024) and new water heater (2024), giving occupants privacy, comfort, and confidence. A renovated garage storage area (2021) rounds out the property's functionality, providing organized space for tools, equipment, or hobby storage. Whether you're looking to house extended family, generate supplemental income, or simply invest in a property where the hard work is already done, this is a rare find in Keystone Heights.

665 Se Heron Street, Keystone Heights
$472,500
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ GC540238 MLS
$10,000 BUYERS CREDIT towards whatever you wish! Check out this stunning 4 bedroom, 4 bathroom lakefront home on Lake Brooklyn! Enjoy breathtaking lake views while sipping your morning coffee from the massive covered porch. Inside, you’ll love the soaring vaulted ceilings with exposed beams that create the perfect cozy cabin feel, along with a beautiful wood-burning fireplace. Vinyl plank flooring runs throughout the home, making maintenance easy and efficient. Three of the four bedrooms feature their own private en-suite bathrooms, offering exceptional comfort and privacy. Upstairs, both bedrooms include private balconies overlooking the property and lake. Downstairs features a spacious living area, private bedroom, and full bathroom, making it ideal for an in-law suite, guest quarters, or even a potential income-producing apartment. Complete with a private dock, this home is perfect for enjoying lake life to the fullest. Don’t miss your opportunity to own this incredible waterfront retreat!

7119 Immokalee Road, Keystone Heights
$247,900
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ GC539704 MLS
Brand new HVAC! This beautifully renovated 3/2 is the perfect blend of modern updates and timeless charm. You'll have just over 1,250 sqft and a fully-fenced backyard in the heart of Keystone Heights, within walking distance to both KHES & KHHS. Step inside and you'll discover new flooring, fresh interior paint, and updated trim that create a bright, clean, and inviting atmosphere throughout. The fully renovated kitchen is a standout feature, complete with solid surface countertops, brand-new stainless steel appliances, and a newly added pantry for extra storage and convenience. The natural light create a warm space to start your day or prep dinner. A flex room off the living room would make a great office, den, or formal dining. Both bathrooms feature brand new vanities and solid surface counters, while thoughtfully retaining the retro, and functional tile features. Outside, the home continues to impress with its welcoming curb appeal and mature landscaping. Enjoy living a stroll away from the historic downtown, with amenities like brand new tennis courts, Keystone Beach, Geneva Jungle Park, and events like annual parades, a lake-side concert series, farmer's markets, and food truck Fridays.

950 S Lawrence Boulevard, Keystone Heights
$239,000
2 Beds ⋅ 1 Baths ⋅ GC539574 MLS
Enjoy peaceful views of Lake Geneva from this charming 2-bedroom, 1-bath concrete block home situated on nearly a quarter-acre lot. With 780 square feet of thoughtfully utilized living space, this property offers a cozy, low-maintenance lifestyle without sacrificing character or functionality. Inside, beautiful wood floors add warmth and timeless appeal, creating an inviting atmosphere throughout the home. The layout is efficient and comfortable, making it ideal as a full-time residence, weekend getaway, or investment opportunity. Washer and dryer are included, and the home is connected to public utilities for everyday convenience. This property is equipped with a Generac back-up generator, providing added peace of mind and reliability year-round. Outside, you’ll find two full carports offering ample covered parking, along with a large shed that has power already run to it—perfect for storage, hobbies, a workshop, or additional workspace. The generous lot size provides room to relax, entertain, or simply enjoy the tranquil lake views and surrounding setting. If you’ve been searching for an affordable home with charm, practical upgrades, and scenic surroundings, this Lake Geneva property is a must-see.

360 Se Lakeview Drive, Keystone Heights
$599,900
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ GC539138 MLS
Enjoy the best of lakefront living in Keystone Heights with this beautifully updated 2-bedroom, 2-bath home set on 4.22 private acres along the shores of scenic Hall Lake. Thoughtfully redesigned, the interior features wood-look tile flooring throughout, an open and inviting layout, and a stylish kitchen with stainless steel appliances and a large island ideal for gathering and everyday living. The oversized owner’s suite offers a comfortable retreat with a walk-in closet and a custom-finished bathroom showcasing detailed tile work and a glass-enclosed shower. Outdoors, the property truly shines with wide water views from the screened porch, a pool and spa for relaxing, and a well-appointed cabana complete with a bar area, industrial-style sink, and its own full bathroom with unique wood and stone accents. Additional features include a detached three-car garage with upper-level storage/loft which could be converted, covered parking for a boat, a generously sized storage shed, and a durable metal roof, all contributing to a move-in ready property designed for both peaceful waterfront living and effortless entertaining.Schedule your tour today!

5119 Heskett Lane, Keystone Heights
$295,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ GC538938 MLS
Tucked away in the peaceful Lake Santa Fe community in Keystone Heights, this inviting 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom home sits on nearly 1.5 acres of land, includes a 6000 Sq-ft Bradford County abandonment of 60Ft right-of-way in rear of property. Built in the early 1990s and thoughtfully maintained over the years, the home tells a story of care and reliability—from its consistently dependable well water system to its sand mound septic system with pump replaced in January 2020. The HVAC replaced in September 2013. Roof also redone in 2013, a newer hot water tank, Electrical Wiring in conduit throughout, visible in the attic and a Surge Blaster installed in the Meter by Clay Electric. The property expands beyond expectations, including additional usable land behind it, with a survey available and clearly marked boundary. A rear garage/shop addition completed in 2020 adds versatility for hobbies or storage, while the main house features warm wood kitchen cabinets and details like brick veneer over solid block construction. Surrounded by nature, the spacious lot offers room to grow and personalize. Less than 10 minutes from Historic Melrose and 25 Minutes to Gainesville. Around the corner from the Boat Ramp to Lake Santa Fe’s 5800 acre, aquifer fed lake for fantastic fishing, water sports and more. Strong structural integrity, updated systems, and endless potential for customization, this home is more than just a place to live—it’s an opportunity to create your own paradise.

2569 Se 50th Street, Keystone Heights
Start Your Search